My son is rude.
He’s only four, and you might say that he’s just forthright and painfully honest. You’d be right.
Yes, he is young. Yes, the things he says that make me cringe are true to him. But they’re still rude.
Navigating him through this has been tricky. I value honesty. I value authenticity. I would rather myself and my children be respected than liked, so I do think it’s okay to communicate unpopular and sometimes difficult truths.
But I also don’t think it’s okay to go around spouting whatever you want, simply because it’s true.
I don’t have much respect for people who take pride in saying whatever is on their mind in any situation. What’s so hard about that?
(And the ironic thing is, they are the ones who often have the hardest time accepting honest comments, and take offense the most.)
So what’s the difference between acceptable honesty and rudeness?
I think it’s motive. Intent.
There have been times where I’ve felt moved to be very frank. One may need to be bluntly honest when the speaker truly loves the hearer, or feels the need to resort to clear, exact speech to articulate the seriousness and reality of something.
In cases where honesty is profitable, the candid speech is meant to benefit the hearer.
That’s a far cry from simply saying an offhand “honest” remark to make a point, put someone in their place, or to just feel better about oneself. If I have to claim “I’m just being honest” instead of “I’m saying this because I love you” I just may have the wrong motivation for sounding off.
Ah, but we were talking about a four-year-old.
For now, we’re just sticking to a “If you can’t say something nice, say nothing” rule.




